
Riharna Thomson: What Can We Say When the Cause Is Uncertain?
We like a clear answer after something goes wrong. Was it the horse? The track? The rider? The equipment? The decision to keep working?
Sometimes a coronial finding cannot honestly choose one explanation. That does not make it a less useful document. It means we have to teach the difference between a hazard, a possible cause, and a fact that has actually been established.
Riharna Thomson's case is a valuable example for people working with horses because it brings together trackwork, animal injury, workplace conversations, fall response and evidence that remained uncertain.
Who was Riharna?
Riharna Louise Thomson was 22 years old, studying political science at the Australian National University and working as a stable assistant at Thoroughbred Park in Canberra. She was an experienced rider who cared deeply about the horses she worked with.
On 28 February 2017, she was riding a thoroughbred mare named Chosen Prayer during trackwork. The horse suffered a catastrophic leg fracture while galloping on the synthetic Acton Track, and Riharna fell. She suffered an unsurvivable head injury and died on 3 March 2017.
The ACT Coroner's Court published findings on 26 May 2022, cited as [2022] ACTCD 3. Coroner Stewart reviewed extensive police and WorkSafe ACT investigations and concluded that a hearing was unnecessary because there was no dispute requiring oral resolution of the expert evidence.
What the court could establish
The finding confirmed the cause of Riharna's death as unsurvivable head injury. It described the manner of death as a rider's fall following a horse's broken leg, with the break either arising from catastrophic bone failure or from the horse being ridden on an inconsistent track.
That choice of words matters. The coroner did not establish that the track caused the fall, but expressly found that its condition was a potential cause. An independent assessment on 16 March 2017, after the fall, found the track unsafe for fast work because of surface inconsistency, and drainage and rectification work followed that month. The precise cause of Chosen Prayer's fracture nevertheless remained unresolved.
In the formal findings, the coroner stated that no matters of public safety had arisen in the matter. This is important to report accurately. It would be wrong to present the investigation as though the coroner officially found the venue negligent or issued a set of binding safety recommendations.
The finding also records concerns raised by riders about inconsistent track conditions. The coroner accepted that some people had tried to notify management, acknowledged subsequent improvements in safety communication and documentation, and questioned the lack of national synthetic-track standards. These are important safety findings even though the coroner could not establish that the track caused Riharna's death.
The moment on the track
Riharna was experienced enough to ride and control the mare. Witnesses described her as competent, dedicated and familiar with Chosen Prayer. The coroner concluded that she was a competent and experienced rider. The horse was travelling at approximately 66 kilometres per hour when it broke its leg, according to data from a tracking device.
No one actually saw the fall itself. A colleague observed horse and rider on the ground and went to help. The track supervisor reached Riharna and reported that she was not breathing initially but began breathing after the supervisor called her name and touched her hand. Riharna's helmet had separated from her head in the accident, although witness evidence was that the chin strap had been fastened.
We should not turn any of that into a definitive explanation for the injury. The coroner noted damage to the helmet and evidence of head impact, but did not establish exactly how Riharna landed beyond the evidence of her head and helmet striking the surface.
For first aiders, the important observation is that a high-speed fall can produce a catastrophic head injury even where the rider is experienced and wearing a helmet. Protective equipment can reduce certain risks, but it is not a guarantee against fatal trauma.
What about the synthetic track?
The investigation included varying opinions about the Acton Track's condition and consistency. Some witnesses raised concerns about softer areas after particular times or around certain sections. Others considered the track suitable and pointed to the routine variation that occurs with racing surfaces.
About two weeks later, on 15 March 2017, another horse suffered a catastrophic shoulder injury and fell in the same soft area after the winning post. WorkSafe ACT closed the track that day. The court considered other incidents as part of its examination, but an incident occurring nearby does not prove that the track caused this particular fall.
The coroner was careful about the limits of the evidence. Riharna had not regained consciousness, nobody witnessed the decisive moments and the investigation could not establish why she was riding at that speed and position or exactly how the horse's fracture occurred.
When teaching workplace safety, I would separate two questions. First: was the condition of a track a subject that could reasonably be monitored and raised? Of course. Second: did the coroner establish that an unsafe track caused Riharna's fatal fall? No.
We do not improve safety by turning a suspicion into a fact. Doing so can actually make future reporting less credible.
Why reporting a concern still matters
Even without a definite causal finding, equine workplaces benefit when people can raise concerns about footing, surfaces, equipment, animal behaviour and handling procedures without the conversation becoming personal.
A stablehand might notice a soft patch on a track. Another rider might feel that a horse is moving differently. A coach may see that an access gate has begun sticking. Each person should know who can assess the concern and how it will be recorded and acted upon.
You do not need a fatal inquest to justify routine hazard reporting. Work health and safety is about identifying and managing risk before an injury occurs, while recognising that not every accident can be traced to a single preventable mistake.
For managers, the practical question is whether there is a usable process for receiving and reviewing concerns. An informal comment in a busy yard may disappear. A clear reporting route lets someone assess whether a change or temporary restriction is needed.
A caution: these are general workplace risk-management lessons. The ACT coroner's formal finding did not determine that a particular unreported concern caused Riharna's death.
When someone falls during trackwork
The first people on the scene may be fellow riders, a track supervisor, a stable assistant or a trainer. They may be close to a distressed or injured horse. They may also be on a live track with other horses approaching.
Scene safety comes first. Get the relevant track control involved and prevent other horses or vehicles entering the area. Do not put yourself between a distressed horse and a barrier, or enter an unsafe track just to reach the casualty a few seconds sooner.
Call emergency help early, giving the correct track location and entry route. Assess the injured person as soon as safe. Check responsiveness and whether they are breathing normally. If unresponsive and not breathing normally, begin CPR and use an AED as soon as possible. If unresponsive but breathing normally, gently roll them into the recovery position while keeping the head, neck and torso aligned without twisting. Keep the airway open and reassess breathing. Airway management takes priority over concern about spinal movement (ANZCOR Guideline 9.1.6).
A brief return of breathing, movement or sound does not mean a serious head injury has resolved. Monitor the casualty until emergency responders take over. Report changes, not assumptions about the type of brain injury.
The court's finding that Riharna's injuries were unsurvivable must not be turned into an argument that first aid was pointless. It establishes the outcome of this particular accident. In a new emergency we assess and respond to the person in front of us.
The helmet question
It is understandable to focus on the helmet because witnesses said it had come off following the fall. The police inspected it and documented evidence of impact and damage. But the finding does not support a simple claim that Riharna had failed to fasten it or that a particular helmet error caused her death.
In an educational article, we should encourage riders to select helmets that meet the relevant current standard and fit them correctly. We should also state their limits. Severe falls can overwhelm protective equipment.
The skill for a first aider is not analysing the helmet at the scene. It is recognising the risk of head and spinal injury, protecting airway and breathing, and getting urgent medical care.
A workplace drill worth running
Here is a practical exercise. A trackwork rider goes down on a bend after the horse stumbles. Another horse is still approaching. The injured rider does not respond when spoken to.
Who stops work on the track? Who makes the emergency call? How do you ensure that an approaching rider can see the danger? Who can safely manage the horse? Where is the AED, and who goes to retrieve it? What is the nearest safe ambulance access point?
Now add the detail that the rider begins breathing after a few moments. Does the team understand that this is still a major emergency? Are they prepared to keep reassessing and not permit a return to riding? What will they tell paramedics about how the rider was found?
You can learn a great deal about your workplace's readiness in ten minutes without recreating the tragedy or distressing anybody with graphic descriptions.
What I want people to leave with
Riharna's death is a tragedy, and the evidence did not provide her family with an unequivocal mechanical explanation for why the horse fell. The court's restraint in expressing its conclusions is something we should respect.
We can hold two ideas at once. We should never claim that an unproven hazard caused a death. We should also maintain strong systems for noticing, reporting and investigating hazards.
In first aid, uncertainty is normal. You may not know precisely why the horse fell, what internal injury the rider has sustained or whether the rider will survive. You can still make useful decisions: make the scene safe, call for help, assess breathing and responsiveness, give first aid within training and communicate clearly.
That is what practical confidence looks like. We act on what we know, stay alert to what changes, and do not invent the parts we cannot know.
Bring this training to your venue
REACHAU delivers first aid training on site at stables, riding schools, pony clubs and equestrian venues. We build the scenarios around your property, your access points and the incidents your riders and staff are most likely to face.
Not sure where your yard stands? Take the free short Horse Safety Quiz.
Primary source
ACT Coroner's Court, Inquest into the death of Riharna Louise Thomson, [2022] ACTCD 3, 26 May 2022, especially paragraphs 1–6, 13–23 and 83–87: www.courts.act.gov.au
Practical training scenario
Imagine this incident happens at a place where you regularly ride or work. You are not the event doctor, the manager or the person who wrote the procedures. You are the person who notices the emergency first. Ask: what is dangerous right now? Who is calling 000 or activating event control? How will the responding team find the casualty? Is the person responsive and breathing normally? What is within my first aid training? Who can secure any horse without putting another person at risk? What changes need to be reported at handover? Practise those questions in the actual environment. A plan which works only in a classroom is an incomplete plan.
A note about first aid scope
If the casualty is unresponsive and not breathing normally, follow DRSABCD, start CPR and use an AED as soon as available. If unresponsive but breathing normally, call 000, gently roll the person into the recovery position, keeping their head, neck and body aligned and avoiding twisting. Keep the airway open and reassess breathing. Airway management takes priority over concern about spinal movement (ANZCOR Guideline 9.1.6). Use current ANZCOR guidance and your level of training. A head or chest injury may need interventions beyond first aid. Do not attempt invasive treatment because it appears in a coronial report.
Why we teach this at REACHAU
My aim is not to turn every rider into a trauma specialist. It is to help people recognise the emergency, understand why early decisions matter and have the confidence to do something useful rather than stand back unsure. The best time to work out where an ambulance enters a property, which channel the officials use, or who retrieves an AED is before anyone is hurt. A Statement of Attainment is evidence of training. Confidence is developed by understanding, practising and using those skills.
