In an emergency, call 000. Training complements but does not replace professional emergency response.
Rider on horseback travelling along a dry track through open country

The Radio Call and the Minutes That Followed: Lessons from the Caitlyn Fischer Inquest

November 15, 2026•12 min read

When somebody falls at a cross-country fence, a great deal can happen in the minutes before professional medical care reaches them. People see the fall from different positions. One person calls on the radio. Another runs towards the rider. A parent may see an incident that nobody should have to witness. The people responding may have different memories of exactly when they arrived.

It is easy to analyse those minutes afterwards with a clock, a transcript and a report. It is much harder to live them. This article is about why clear communication, realistic positioning and rehearsed decisions matter, not about blaming the people caught in a terrible emergency.

The person behind the finding

Caitlyn Fischer, aged 19, died on 30 April 2016 after a fall in the cross-country phase of an eventing competition at the Sydney International Equestrian Centre in Horsley Park, New South Wales. The NSW coroner found that the cause of death was blunt force head injuries and the manner was accidental misadventure.

Caitlyn and Olivia Inglis, who died in a different eventing incident earlier in 2016, were the subjects of concurrent inquests. Deputy State Coroner Derek Lee delivered findings on 4 October 2019 with a consolidated set of recommendations. The concurrent inquest into Olivia Inglis examined wider medical resources and readiness; here, our focus is Caitlyn's particular circumstances and the response-time evidence. The official Olivia Inglis findings are available at https://coroners.nsw.gov.au/documents/findings/2019/INGLIS%20Olivia%20-%20Findings.pdf.

This is sensitive material. The court made non-publication orders covering certain scene photographs and video of Caitlyn's fall. We have no reason to publish, reproduce or seek that material for education. What matters is the publicly available written finding.

What happened at fence two

The court examined the chronology of Caitlyn's ride and fall, including video timing, radio communications, statements and telephone records. The finding records that Caitlyn started the cross-country phase at approximately 10:40 am and fell at fence two at about 10:40:30 am.

The fence judge immediately raised the alarm on the radio. The court described evidence that she made an initial urgent medical call approximately eleven seconds after the fall. She later repeated her call, provided Caitlyn's identifying number and tried to signal towards the medical vehicle.

There were people nearby who reached Caitlyn before the organised medical response. Their efforts and observations were described during the inquest. Different witnesses remembered different sequences and different response times. Those inconsistencies were understandable in light of how distressing the circumstances were, but they made the chronology important to examine.

The coroner considered the available video and records and found it most likely that the first medical response arrived at least five minutes after the fall. That conclusion was not based on a simplistic allegation that somebody deliberately ignored a call. The court assessed conflicting recollections, the way the radio calls were understood, the position and movement of responders, and the absence of a definitive event clock connecting all the evidence.

Five minutes is not the whole story

The inquest found that witnesses had very different perceptions of the wait. Some thought it lasted an eternity. Others thought the response was relatively prompt. The coroner was careful about exact timing because memories formed during a traumatic event are not the same as synchronised recordings.

This is one of the most useful insights for teaching. We cannot expect a witness who has just seen someone seriously injured to produce an accurate timeline from memory alone. If we want to know what happened afterwards, our event system should record calls, dispatch and arrival times as reliably as possible. It also needs to provide reassurance to the person on the radio that the message has been received and acted on.

The court found there was no evidence the fence judge's radio equipment malfunctioned or that she did not know how to use it. Nor did it identify evidence for the suggestion that she pressed the wrong button. At least one of her reported calls was not explained by other witnesses hearing it. The court observed that an estimated arrival time from the responding team could have reassured the fence judge.

We should be careful not to twist this into a claim that an ETA would have changed Caitlyn's medical outcome. It is a communication lesson: when the person who reported a critical incident cannot tell whether help is coming, they may repeat information, become more distressed or struggle to coordinate the scene.

The reply that matters

In scenario training, I want the radio call to do three jobs. It identifies an incident, it tells the response team where to go, and it establishes that the request has been acknowledged.

A practical message might be: “Control, urgent medical at fence two. Rider down, unresponsive. Horse clear of the fence. Please confirm.” This is an invented example for training, not a quotation from the 2016 event or a replacement for an organiser's prescribed communications procedure.

When control replies, the next information should be actionable: help dispatched; which route or access point is being used; whether the phase is being stopped; what the reporting official should do next. Keep messages short. On a busy radio channel, lengthy explanations can push out essential information.

The person at the fence does not need to diagnose a brain injury. They do need to say whether the rider is moving, responsive or breathing normally if they have safely assessed those things. If the rider's condition changes, say so. State uncertainty rather than inventing certainty.

Why positioning is a first aid issue

The court examined where the medical teams were stationed and how quickly they could travel to a casualty. One medical team was stationed near the water complex and the other at event control. The coroner examined how long it took responders to reach fence two, including the difficulty of the route.

There is a lesson here for event planning: do not assume the most technically demanding obstacle is the only place where a catastrophic injury might occur. A fall near the start, near the finish or between expected high-risk locations still needs a practical response route.

This is why a map is not enough. Somebody needs to test the access route with the actual vehicle, in the actual conditions. Can the team leave its station promptly? Is a gate open? Does the route cross other competition areas? If multiple phases are operating, how are conflicting movements controlled?

The 2019 recommendations called for a properly planned level of medical staffing and deployment, including a target of three minutes or less for a serious incident, where possible on cross-country. That was a recommendation for the eventing rules. It is not a universal guarantee of arrival, nor an instruction for lay first aiders to wait three minutes before doing anything.

When the first person is not a clinician

At many events, a fence judge or spectator reaches the rider first. Their responsibilities may be very different from those of the event's medical team.

Their first decision is whether they can approach without exposing themselves to a horse, another rider or moving equipment. Their next is to call for help through the correct channel. If they are trained and the scene is safe, they can assess responsiveness and normal breathing, give first aid within their level of training and keep monitoring the person.

Caitlyn's finding described distressing efforts made by those nearby to help before medical responders arrived. It also records that family members were present, an extraordinarily difficult circumstance for everybody involved. We need to read those passages as evidence about an emergency, not as an invitation to criticise people from a comfortable distance.

If an unresponsive person is not breathing normally, begin CPR and arrange for an AED as soon as possible. If the person is unresponsive but breathing normally, call 000 and gently roll them into the recovery position, keeping their head, neck and torso aligned without twisting. Keep their airway open and reassess breathing. Airway care takes priority over possible spinal injury (ANZCOR Guideline 9.1.6).

Someone else can secure the scene, stop further horses approaching and guide responders. Those activities support the first aider rather than competing with first aid. Assigning clear jobs also reduces the number of people crowding around the casualty.

What if the radio is quiet?

This is the next scenario I would put to a group of volunteers.

You have sent a priority call. There is no response. You send it again. You still cannot tell whether anyone heard you.

What is your backup? Is there a secondary radio channel, mobile number or event-control position? Is there somebody who can use another communication method without leaving the casualty alone? Does the event's emergency plan tell you when to make a direct 000 call if response is not confirmed?

We cannot invent a single rule for every event. What matters is that organisers specify the escalation procedure, brief volunteers and rehearse the failure case. The worst time to discover that everybody assumes somebody else is making the call is during a major injury.

The same question applies in stable yards and on trails. A phone may have no coverage. One person may know the property address but be elsewhere. The gate nearest the casualty may be locked. First aid training should sit within a real-world access and communications plan.

After the incident, use records with care

The court spent considerable effort reconciling witness testimony. It was not possible to determine every second precisely. That is a reminder that even detailed records cannot always provide perfect certainty when separate systems are not synchronised.

Organisers should document when an incident was reported, when the response was dispatched, who attended, whether the competition was stopped and when specialist services arrived. Keep the process simple enough to complete under pressure. After an event, compare the records to the plan so the next event can improve.

Do not assess a volunteer's performance solely through one disputed estimate of time. Look at what the system enabled that person to do. Did they have a working radio? Were they trained in priority calls? Did control answer? Was there a clear secondary route for urgent communication? Could responders reach the location?

The lesson I would teach

Caitlyn was more than the incident at fence two. The public finding describes a young woman and the enormous loss experienced by those who loved her. We cannot turn her death into a neat promise that one radio procedure or different placement of a medical vehicle would have prevented it.

We can, however, use the findings to ask important questions before the next event.

Do we know the exact response pathway for every part of our course? Can volunteers send urgent messages that get acknowledged? Do we have a backup when communication fails? Have we practised the moment between the fall and the arrival of the medical team?

The difference between a document called an emergency plan and a team ready for an emergency is practice.

Bring this training to your venue

REACHAU delivers first aid training on site at stables, riding schools, pony clubs and equestrian venues. We build the scenarios around your property, your access points and the incidents your riders and staff are most likely to face.

Not sure where your yard stands? Take the free short Horse Safety Quiz.

Request an on-site quote

Related case

For the shared 2019 recommendations on equipment, medical staffing and wider event systems, read the official Olivia Inglis finding linked in the sources below. The two findings were considered concurrently, but the incidents and their circumstances must not be merged.

Primary source

  • NSW Coroner's Court, Inquest into the Death of Caitlyn Fischer, 4 October 2019, particularly sections 12 and 13 and Appendix A: coroners.nsw.gov.au

  • Additional reference: NSW Coroner's Court, Inquest into the Death of Olivia Inglis, 4 October 2019. Equestrian Australia's event statement confirms Caitlyn was 19: www.equestrian.org.au

  • Olivia Inglis finding: coroners.nsw.gov.au

For current event requirements, organisers should refer to the latest Equestrian Australia National Eventing Rules and any applicable local arrangements.

Practical training scenario

Imagine this incident happens at a place where you regularly ride or work. You are not the event doctor, the manager or the person who wrote the procedures. You are the person who notices the emergency first. Ask: what is dangerous right now? Who is calling 000 or activating event control? How will the responding team find the casualty? Is the person responsive and breathing normally? What is within my first aid training? Who can secure any horse without putting another person at risk? What changes need to be reported at handover? Practise those questions in the actual environment. A plan which works only in a classroom is an incomplete plan.

A note about first aid scope

If the casualty is unresponsive and not breathing normally, follow DRSABCD, start CPR and use an AED as soon as available. If unresponsive but breathing normally, call 000, gently roll the person into the recovery position, keeping their head, neck and body aligned and avoiding twisting. Keep the airway open and reassess breathing. Airway management takes priority over concern about spinal movement (ANZCOR Guideline 9.1.6). Use current ANZCOR guidance and your level of training. A head or chest injury may need interventions beyond first aid. Do not attempt invasive treatment because it appears in a coronial report.

Why we teach this at REACHAU

My aim is not to turn every rider into a trauma specialist. It is to help people recognise the emergency, understand why early decisions matter and have the confidence to do something useful rather than stand back unsure. The best time to work out where an ambulance enters a property, which channel the officials use, or who retrieves an AED is before anyone is hurt. A Statement of Attainment is evidence of training. Confidence is developed by understanding, practising and using those skills.

Britt Brennan

Britt Brennan

Britt Brennan is an Empowerment-Focused First Aid Trainer and Employment Coach, with a Bachelor of Health Science and a Diploma of Mental Health. Through REACHAU, Britt delivers practical first aid training across Perth and regional Western Australia. Her teaching focuses on understanding why first aid techniques work, practising the skills and building the confidence to use them in a real emergency. Britt believes there is a big difference between being certified and being capable. Her goal is for every participant to leave knowing they can make a difference when someone needs help.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog