
Emergency Phone Access in Childcare: Why Supervision and a Plan Come First
Emergency Phone Access in Childcare: Why Supervision and a Plan Come First
What a Western Australian coronial finding teaches us about supervision around water, and about making sure someone can always call for help.
By Britt Brennan, REACHAU | 17 November 2026

There are few things harder to read about than the death of a small child. This article is written with respect for Lachlan, for his family, and for everyone who cares for young children.
Lachlan's parents asked for the inquest, and they have campaigned for change since. The coroner's finding gives families, carers, educators and services a reason to think carefully about two things: supervision around water, and being able to call for help the moment it is needed.
What the coroner found
What the finding says
The inquest into the death of Lachlan James Mitchell was heard in the Perth Coroner's Court, and the finding was delivered on 30 May 2018. Lachlan was two years old. In November 2015 he was in a family day care service run from a private home, where there was a fenced swimming pool. He went outside with the carer. She then went inside to settle a baby and called the children to follow. Lachlan stayed outside, and she found him in the pool. The coroner found the cause of death was consistent with hypoxic brain injury following immersion (drowning), and the manner of death was accident.
The coroner found that direct supervision would have prevented Lachlan from entering the pool. She stressed that the window to save a child in this situation is very short, and that a pool barrier cannot replace supervision. The coroner could not determine exactly how Lachlan entered the pool, or for how long he was unsupervised.
The carer began CPR as soon as she pulled him from the water. She could not find her mobile phone, so she stopped and ran to neighbours to ask them to call an ambulance. The phone was later found inside the pool fence. A neighbour with current CPR skills then continued CPR, with guidance from a call taker, until the ambulance arrived.
The coroner did not make a finding about whether the time taken to call for help changed the outcome. That is not something the record can tell us, and it is important not to guess.
The coroner made four recommendations to the Minister for Child Protection and Community Services. They included considering legislation to stop family day care operating from homes with a pool, monthly inspections of pool barriers for existing educators, and requiring a fixed landline at each educator's home. These were proposals for government in 2018. They are not a description of current law, and regulations have been changed since.
Anything else in this article is my teaching suggestion. It is not a finding of the coroner, and it is not a judgement about what anyone should have done on the day.
Supervision comes first
ANZCOR guidance on drowning is clear that prevention is the most important step. Pool fencing significantly reduces the risk to children, and children being supervised in or near water need close and constant attention.
Barriers matter, but they are one layer. A gate can be left unlatched. A child can climb. The coroner's finding makes the same point: barriers cannot replace supervision.
Some practical questions for any home, centre or event with water:
- Who is the named supervisor right now, and are they watching the water?
- If that person needs to leave, who has accepted the job, out loud, before they go?
- Can children reach the water without an adult noticing?
- Are there objects near the fence that a child could climb?
These are my suggestions. They apply to pools, but also to dams, baths, spas, ponds and water tanks.
Make the call as easy as possible
In an emergency, you do not want to be searching for a phone. The finding records that the carer's phone ended up inside the pool fence, because she dropped it when she went in. She then had to leave the child to get help.
The coroner's recommendation about a fixed landline was addressed to government and specific to family day care. In any setting where children are near water, the principle is worth thinking about.
A question to talk through
If something happened in the next minute, where is the phone, who would call 000, and could they do it without leaving the person who needs CPR?
Some ideas to consider, which are my own suggestions:
- Keep a charged phone in a known, easy to reach spot near the water, such as a waterproof pouch on the fence or a wall mounted holder.
- If someone else is present, name them as the person who calls 000 so the person doing CPR can stay with the child.
- Learn how to put a phone on speaker, so the call taker can guide you while your hands are free.
- Know your address, or the exact location, and practise saying it clearly.
- Make sure neighbours, other adults and older children know the plan.
If a child is pulled from the water
ANZCOR guidance for drowning includes these key points:
- Remove the person from the water as soon as possible without putting yourself in danger, and call for help.
- If the child is unresponsive and not breathing normally, start CPR with 30 compressions and 2 breaths. Do not wait for an AED or oxygen to arrive.
- Rescue breaths matter in drowning, because the main problem is the interrupted oxygen supply. ANZCOR strongly discourages compression only CPR except as a temporary measure if you cannot give breaths.
- If the airway is blocked with fluid or vomit, roll the person onto their side to drain, then return to CPR with as little interruption as possible. Do not try to clear froth.
- Use an AED as soon as one is available. ANZCOR states that using an AED on a wet surface such as poolside is not dangerous.
- Everyone involved in a drowning incident needs an ambulance and a medical assessment, even if they seem to have recovered.
Children and infants need techniques adapted to their size. Those are best learned hands-on, with an infant and child manikin and a qualified trainer giving you feedback.
The neighbour in this case had current CPR skills. The ambulance officers noted that the CPR was effective. That is a quiet reminder of why current skills in a community matter.
A note on timing and uncertainty
The finding records that the carer's estimate of how long she was away was uncertain, and Lachlan's parents doubted it. The pathologist's evidence was that it does not take long for a young child to drown, and that serious brain injury can happen in as little as two to four minutes.
I mention this to be honest about what the record shows. The facts of exactly how long are not known, and this article does not try to fill the gap. What is clear is that the time is short, and that is why prevention comes first.
Looking after yourself afterwards
Anyone who has been involved in an emergency like this, as a carer, a neighbour or a family member, can carry a heavy weight. It is normal to replay it and to feel shaken for some time. Our guide on looking after yourself after giving first aid explains what is common and when it is a good idea to see a GP.
Frequently asked questions
Is a pool fence enough to keep a young child safe?
No. Pool fencing significantly reduces risk, but ANZCOR guidance also stresses close and constant supervision, and the coroner in this case noted that barriers cannot replace supervision.
What should I do first if I find a child in the water?
Remove the child from the water as soon as possible without endangering yourself, and call for help. If the child is unresponsive and not breathing normally, start CPR with 30 compressions and 2 breaths, and use an AED when one arrives.
Should I wait for the ambulance before starting CPR?
No. Start CPR straight away and keep going until help arrives or the child starts breathing normally. If someone else is with you, ask them to call 000 so you can stay with the child.
Does CPR for a drowned child include rescue breaths?
Yes. In drowning the main problem is the interrupted oxygen supply, so ANZCOR guidance includes rescue breaths. Compression only CPR is strongly discouraged except as a temporary measure if you cannot give breaths.
Is it safe to use an AED on a wet surface?
ANZCOR guidance states that using an AED on a wet surface such as poolside is not dangerous. Follow the AED prompts and make sure no one is touching the person when it delivers a shock.
Does this finding describe the current rules for family day care?
No. The coroner's recommendations were proposals to government in 2018. Rules for education and care services have changed since, so check the current requirements for your service.
Sources and current guidance
- Coronial finding: Inquest into the death of Lachlan James Mitchell, Coroner's Court of Western Australia
- ANZCOR Guideline 9.3.2, Resuscitation in drowning
REACHAU first aid training focuses on understanding what to do, why it matters and how to act when someone needs help.
View upcoming first aid sessionsTraining and Assessment is delivered by Britt at Regional Education and Career Help Australia on behalf of ABC First Aid RTO 3399.
Related reading
- DRSABCD: the first aid action plan
- CPR and AED first aid guide
- After the emergency: looking after yourself when you helped
This article shares learning points from a published coronial finding and current ANZCOR guidance. The recommendations in the finding are historical proposals made in 2018, not a description of current childcare law. It is general information, not a complete treatment guide or safety advice, and it does not replace hands-on training. In an emergency, call 000.
