
Who Is Watching Their Breathing? A First Aid Teamwork Lesson
Who Is Watching Their Breathing? A First Aid Teamwork Lesson
What a Western Australian coronial finding teaches us about naming who is watching a person, and speaking up the moment something changes.
By Britt Brennan, REACHAU | 1 December 2026

When several people are helping at an emergency, it is easy to assume someone else is watching. Everyone is busy, everyone is focused on their own task, and nobody is looking at the person's face.
This article looks at a published Western Australian coronial finding where that gap was named by the coroner. It is written with respect for Josh, whose family asked that he be called by that name, and with care for the officers who were doing a difficult job. It is about teamwork. It is not a guide to restraint, and it should not be read as one.
What the coroner found
What the finding says
The inquest into the death of Joshua Fredrik Van Malssen was heard in January 2026, and the finding was delivered on 2 February 2026 by the Acting Deputy State Coroner. Josh was 24. He died on 16 June 2023 after an incident with Public Transport Authority transit officers at Perth Underground station. The coroner found that he went into cardiac arrest while being restrained in a prone position, in a man with several health conditions and with alcohol effect. The manner of death was misadventure.
The coroner found that the arrest and restraint were justified and appropriate, and that the interaction was respectful and in line with policy and training. The coroner also found that the standard of monitoring while he was prone was poor.
The finding records that there was no communication between the officers about who was monitoring him or about his welfare, and that there should have been. CCTV shows he appeared to take several deep breaths and then lost consciousness, and this seems to have gone unnoticed until after the handcuffs were secured. An officer then noticed he was unresponsive and ordered the handcuffs removed, and CPR was started. A defibrillator was applied, but no shock was advised. Paramedics took over, and he was declared dead at hospital that night.
The coroner could not conclude, to the required standard, that the acts or omissions of any officer caused his death. The coroner also found that the restraint in the prone position contributed to the death, because of his physical and physiological factors. It was not possible to say the outcome would necessarily have been different had CPR started earlier.
All five recommendations were to the Public Transport Authority, and it accepted them. They included more detailed monitoring guidance, regular practical refresher scenarios on monitoring a person held face down, contextualised life support training, a review of the handcuffs used for people of larger build, and a formal review after any critical incident.
Everything else in this article is my teaching reflection. It is not a finding of the coroner.
The lesson for the rest of us
Most of us will never be involved in a restraint. Most of us will be at an emergency with other helpers. The same gap can appear in a first aid room, on a work site, at a sports ground or at a family gathering.
The gap is simple. When no one has been given the job of watching the person, no one watches. And when the person who is watching does not know how to say what they see, or does not feel able to speak up, the change in breathing goes unspoken.
This is not about blame. The coroner noted that three officers agreed in hindsight that he had not been effectively monitored. It is about the system around the people, and what we can do to make sure it works.
A simple way to share the jobs
If you are with others at an emergency, agree on roles out loud. These are my suggestions, adapted from standard first aid teamwork.
- Leader. One person coordinates, makes decisions and keeps track of time.
- Caller. One person calls 000 and fetches the AED.
- Monitor. One person stays with the casualty and watches their breathing, colour and responsiveness. This is their only job.
- Helpers. Others support, control the scene or keep bystanders back.
If you are the only helper, you are the monitor. That is one reason we recommend a first aid course. It builds the habit of constantly re-checking.
The monitor needs a clear sentence to say when something changes. Something like "breathing has changed" or "not responding" is enough. The leader needs to stop and act when they hear it.
What ANZCOR guidance says
ANZCOR Guideline 3 is about the unconscious person. It is not about restraint, and I am only using it by analogy. It includes these points:
- Check for danger first.
- Check for a response by talking and touching. Someone who does not respond, or only groans without opening their eyes, should be managed as if unconscious.
- If the person is unresponsive and not breathing normally, follow the CPR steps in Guideline 8. Start compressions, call 000 and use an AED when it arrives.
- If the person is unresponsive and breathing normally, a side lying (recovery) position is suggested.
- Make sure the airway stays open.
- Constantly re-check the person's condition for any change.
- Ideally, the most experienced rescuer stays with the person.
The key phrase is "constantly re-check". A person can be breathing normally one minute and not the next.
A question for your team
If a person at our workplace became unresponsive, who would be watching their breathing, and what would they say if it changed?
Practice that builds the habit
- Run a short drill where one person's only job is to call out "breathing" or "not breathing" every ten seconds.
- Practise handover in the same way. The monitor tells the new person what changed and when.
- Make it normal for the quietest person to speak up. Encourage junior staff to say what they see.
- After a drill, ask what each person noticed and what they would do differently.
Members of the public should never try to restrain anyone. If someone is unwell, intoxicated or agitated, keep back, call 000 and give simple, calm instructions. Specialist work like security and transit policing needs specialist, scenario based training.
Looking after yourself afterwards
After an emergency in which someone has died, helpers and witnesses can find it hard to settle. Our guide on looking after yourself after giving first aid explains what is common and when it is worth seeing a GP.
Frequently asked questions
Why should one person be named as the monitor?
In a team, everyone can assume someone else is watching. Naming one person whose only job is to watch breathing and colour makes sure it happens, and gives them permission to speak up.
What should the monitor look for?
Normal breathing, skin colour and any response. If the person stops responding or stops breathing normally, say so out loud straight away.
What should I do if the person becomes unresponsive?
Check for danger, call 000, and if the person is not breathing normally, start CPR with 30 compressions and 2 breaths. Use an AED as soon as it arrives.
Does this finding teach restraint techniques?
No. It is a teamwork and monitoring lesson. Members of the public should not restrain anyone, and this article does not describe how to.
Did the coroner find that an officer caused the death?
No. The coroner could not conclude that any officer's acts or omissions caused the death. The coroner did find the standard of monitoring was poor, and that restraint in the prone position contributed.
How can a team practise this?
Run drills with clear roles, including a named monitor, and practise short, clear communication. A hands-on first aid course gives you realistic practice.
Sources and current guidance
- Coronial finding: Inquest into the death of Joshua Fredrik Van Malssen, Coroner's Court of Western Australia
- ANZCOR Guideline 3, Recognition and first aid management of the unconscious person
- ANZCOR Guideline 8, Cardiopulmonary resuscitation
REACHAU first aid training focuses on understanding what to do, why it matters and how to act when someone needs help.
View upcoming first aid sessionsTraining and Assessment is delivered by Britt at Regional Education and Career Help Australia on behalf of ABC First Aid RTO 3399.
Related reading
- DRSABCD: the first aid action plan
- CPR and AED first aid guide
- After the emergency: looking after yourself when you helped
This article shares learning points from a published coronial finding and current ANZCOR guidance. It is a teamwork lesson for first aiders and workplaces. It is not instruction in restraining anyone, and members of the public should never try to restrain someone. It does not replace hands-on training. In an emergency, call 000.
